- 2002London adds telescopic urinals that rise from the pavement at night, a type first developed and installed in the Netherlands.
- 2009Miguel Melgarejo’s Axixa, a ceramic wall urinal shaped like a urine stain, circulates on design and tech sites as a concept.
- 2012Melgarejo begins working on the Reinvent the Toilet Challenge at TU Delft, a sanitation project backed by the Bill & Melinda Gates Foundation.
- 2016Amsterdam installs the first retractable public urinal for women.
- 2018Paris trials the Uritrottoir, a waterless, straw-filled street urinal by the French studio Faltazi, and meets protests on the Île Saint-Louis.
What it was
In July 2009, a design proposal from Mexico made the rounds of tech blogs. Miguel Melgarejo, who had finished his industrial design degree in Monterrey the year before, had drawn a public urinal that looked like the problem it was meant to solve. Axixa was a ceramic fixture in the shape of the mark a stream leaves on a wall, to be mounted on the street side of a building. The name is a Nahuatl word for urinating.
The logic was blunt. Some walls get used no matter what the signs say. Rather than fight that with fines, Melgarejo proposed giving those walls a fixture that catches what would otherwise run down onto the pavement, and making the fixture resemble the stain it replaces. His own description called it a symbolic stain that keeps the street clean. Gizmodo filed it as a concept and doubted that shop owners would want one on their facade.
A public urinal can solve the hygiene and still fail on the question of who has to look at it.
What cities built instead
Axixa never left the portfolio. On Melgarejo’s website it sat in a section labeled concepts. He went on to study strategic product design at TU Delft, and from 2012 he worked on the Reinvent the Toilet Challenge there, a Gates Foundation program that developed sanitation for informal settlements in India. The interest in toilets turned out to be serious.
Cities, meanwhile, kept the problem and solved it with less poetry. The Netherlands had already developed telescopic urinals that rise out of the pavement for the night and sink out of sight by day. London added them in 2002, and by 2014 more than 200 were in use across five European countries. In 2016 Amsterdam installed the first retractable urinal for women.
Paris tried a different form in 2018. The Uritrottoir, by the French studio Faltazi, is a red box topped with plants and filled with straw instead of water. The straw is collected about every three weeks and composted. Three went in during a spring trial, and a fourth on the Île Saint-Louis, where residents and business owners protested against an open urinal in full view of the river.
What it means now
The street urinals that did get built share Axixa’s starting point. They accept that people will relieve themselves outside, mostly at night, and design for that instead of against it. Where they differ is visibility. The Dutch units hide underground by day. The Uritrottoir is dressed as a planter. Axixa wanted to be seen, a permanent mark on the wall.
Paris showed why that is the hard part. A urinal can be hygienic, waterless and even compostable, and still fail on the question of who has to look at it. Most designs also still serve men first. Melgarejo’s stain was a joke with a real argument inside it, and the argument, that public sanitation is a design problem and not only a policing one, has aged better than the joke.
The original post, summarized
Our 2009 post introduced Axixa as a public urinal concept by Mexican designer Miguel Melgarejo, a ceramic wall fixture shaped like a urine stain and meant to keep city streets cleaner. It is summarized here rather than republished.
Sources
- Gizmodo: Axixa Urinal Encourages You To Pee On the Side Of Buildings (July 27, 2009)
- Miguel Melgarejo: portfolio site listing Axixa under concepts (archived 2013)
- Miguel Melgarejo: CV with education and Reinvent the Toilet Challenge role (archived 2022)
- Nahuatl Dictionary (Wired Humanities Projects): axixa
- Wikipedia: Telescopic toilet
- France 24: In Paris, eco-friendly cubist urinals spark sniggers and seething (Aug 13, 2018)
- CBS News: Paris open-air urinals not popular among all French (Aug 2018)
- Pop-Up Toilet Company: UriLift Combi
